,,As
a follow up to our last two articles, ISR
invited readers to
submit ideas on how to remedy
the International Teaching Candidate shortage.
We have posted these solutions below and wish to thank the
many teachers who took the time to send their ideas.
,,On
the 28th of May, we invited Search
Associates, TIE, ISS, AISH, COIS, and more, to review
comments
found in this article, and our two previous articles.
We also invited these organizations to comment on
the situation and to share any
solutions they may
have
in the workst. You'll find a link to the email we sent
at the close of this article. |
Teachers' Solutions
to International Teaching Candidate Shortage |
 |
There are several ways to increase the number
of teachers applying to teach overseas. 1) Get the word out. When I
tell my fellow teachers about
my working overseas they get excited. Several have asked me for
information about various recruitment fairs. I actually went to one
with a friend who was interested in what I was doing, and she took
a job
in China.
2) The benefits packages are not what they once were at many schools.
Pay has stayed steady when inflation and cost of living have gone up.
This year I used most of my relocation money on a plane ticket (sky
high airfares out of my home terminal) and have little left to ship
my personal belongings and will have to just bite the bullet on that
one and pay out of pocket. It is important for schools to keep up with
the times when it comes to contracts or those schools will have difficulty
getting and retaining staff.
3) Our Media portrays some countries as more dangerous than they
are. Many people are afraid to travel right now. I interviewed with
a school in a country many feel is not safe. I asked about the safety
and was not given any concrete information. It would help recruiters
to offer statistics and demonstrate what they are doing to keep their
staff safe.
4) Many schools are attempting to cater to the
needs of parents and students with out adjusting to the current concerns
and needs
of staff. The Board of Directors of many schools need to pay closer
attention to the needs of their staff, or they won't have much to
choose from.
 |
.....I suspect that if administrators
were evaluated by their teaching staff, and this had an impact
on administrator salary and school funding/standing, things would
change in a hurry.
Continued operation of sites like ISR at least gets the word
out there, and if "schools
of ill repute" do not want to change then they can simply grumble
and groan at the high proportion of inexperienced and young faculty
they recruit relative to the better schools who have "figured it
out".
As an earlier post said--they understand their part of the "game",
for many of us it is not a game, but you need to play by the rules
if you are going to survive--so until something changes and business
becomes
more fair and equitable--inform yourself and always have a "plan
b " if
you want to live and teach overseas.
 |
There needs to be a system of accountability
in place where genuine complaints and concerns can be dealt with
by an objective individual. While schools should have committees
to deal with in-house issues, the parameters should be specific.
There are concerns/complaints that fall outside of those parameters.
I suggest some of the recruiting and accrediting organizations
have an ombudsperson to deal with those issues relevant to their
organizations.
One of the most significant problems I see is that school administration/leadership/management
is not held accountable. They should be accountable to the stakeholders
in the organization but this simply is not realistic in many cases.
I do not believe that the international system should mirror the
accountability in place in Australia, Canada, the US or the UK, but
something should be in place. Recruiting agencies are supposed to
screen applicants, including administrators and directors, and should
therefore bear some of the responsibility for addressing problems;
CIS, NEASC, WASC and Middle States as well as others accredit the
schools and should also bear some responsibility when relevant issues
emerge. If the sole source of information is the head of the school
but it is that individual who is the problem, how can teachers move
forward positively if at all? For example, if a director has the
power to manipulate contracts or working conditions, to suggest that
the host country has jurisdiction is misleading and in some cases
dangerous. It seems as though in many cases one person has the power
to morale
and school culture as well as the management and direction of the
school. Should the school community be forced to accept this without
recourse? I cannot imagine that any effective organization functions
like this regardless of its location.
 |
International
schools do themselves a vast disservice when they enforce unrealistic
retirement ages, as many in the middle east and
Asia seem to do. As one correspondent mentioned there is a large
group of retirees out there who are seasoned, professional,and
willing and ready for an international experience. Since we are
already drawing
pensions from our retirement plans back home we are even willing
to work for less, simply to have the opportunity to live and travel
overseas. Year after year I see rookie teachers hired, and they
always seem to put in their two years, and then go back home.
The older
teachers are much more willing to stay on, but are often forced
to leave due to an unrealistic "retirement age" policy. Certainly
it might mean more expense in insurance coverage for the schools,
but the tradeoff would be worth it. Very few of the older
teachers I work with are "burned out". Most would love
to continue working.
 |
There are schools that are businesses, not schools. There are teachers
who are there for travel, not teaching. Administrators are making
whopping huge salaries with benefits only dreamed of in the US
without accountability, and we wonder why there is a shortage of
overseas teachers.
Please someone start a recruiting fair that is fair. Keep the
wacko schools and teachers without licenses away. Publish the
real data on the schools, not funky teacher/student ratios that
somehow reduce class size to a fictional number that is enticing.
Publish real salary and benefit information. (What is a competitive
salary?)Arrange interviews that allow for discussion. Make it
professional, not grueling.
Don't make me get letters of reference from former administrators,
most of whom have passed away or were criminally inept, or jump
through dozens of hoops that have nothing to do with teaching
students. Working teachers don't have time to fill out endless
paperwork. Where's the real recruiting fair? That's where the
teachers will be.
Schools need an accreditation system teachers can trust. Schools
claim to have any number of accreditations but these do not assure
teachers of any trusted form of expected working conditions.
My husband and I were at the NY job fair also. It turned out to be
a VERY expensive venture. Before we got there we new what jobs were
available and had read all the available reviews for the schools
involved.
The job fair turned out to be a total waste of time, money and energy
for us because the job opportunities that suited us came from the
schools that had questionable records. We declined 2 positions because
of what we had read about the admim.and then were confirmed in the
interview.
We did notice that the rookie teachers were being snapped up. The
more experienced international teachers seemed to be very depressed
about the quality of the schools and the administrators. I guess
I would have to agree that there are plenty of teachers out there
- but who willingly wants to be treated badly.
ISR does a great job of providing information to the International
teacher and as a result a lot are looking twice instead of jumping
on the plane. Maybe the administrators will eventually figure this
out and then act to do a better job! I also wonder if some schools
are staying out of the job fairs because they realize they are now
dealing with applicants who may know a fair bit about their school
already.
As for my husband and I, our ISS file is inactive for a year. I can't
see us ever doing this again unless a LOT changes.