uu
Return to Preview 


School: Colegio International de Caracas - Caracas, Venezuela
Director's name: Win Sargent 1999 - 2005 / Alan Benson 2006 - 2008
Dates covered: 1999 - 2008

 
Evaluation 6. / Alan Benson 2008
 
Academic integrity of school 10 is top score
9
Effectiveness of administration
8
Academic and disciplinary support provided
9
Director's involvement in academics
10
Fair and equitable treatment by board and director
10
School has adequate educational materials on hand
9
Attitude of local community towards foreigners
9
Cost of living in relation to salary (10= most favorable)
9
Satisfaction with housing
10
Community offers a variety of activities
10
Availability and quality of local health care
10
Assistance with visas, shipping and air travel
10
Extra curricular load is reasonable
10
           

Comments: CIC makes a special effort to go the extra mile for all the students. Students have the opportunity to receive support from the teachers in the areas where they might experience some difficulty. CIC has a very warm atmosphere and relationships between faculty and families are very strong and sincere.

 
Evaluation 5). Alan Benson 2006 - 2007
 
 
Academic integrity of school
8
Effectiveness of administration
9
Academic and disciplinary support provided
9
Director's involvement in academics
9
Fair and equitable treatment by board and director
9
School has adequate educational materials on hand
8
Attitude of local community towards foreigners
8
Cost of living in relation to salary (10= most favorable)
8
Satisfaction with housing
9
Community offers a variety of activities
10
Availability and quality of local health care
8
Assistance with visas, shipping and air travel
9
Extra curricular load is reasonable
10
           

Comments: CIC is a wonderful school with a very strong and dedicated faculty and a hard-working, cooperative support staff. There have been financial challenges over the past few years because of declining enrolment resulting from unstable political conditions but that is changing and enrolment is improving now. The school offers a wide variety of academic courses and a strong activities program. Service to others less fortunate is a major cultural value shared by students, faculty, administration, and staff. CIC offers the IB MYP and IB Diploma Program as well as a standard US Diploma option.

The ARTS are a key feature of the school. The Board and its committees are highly functioning and include faculty and student input. The housing for expats is high quality and their salaries are very competitive. Key activities programs of the school are in varsity and non-varsity sports, MUN, service through the Ayuda y Amistad (AYA) program and various artistic, musical, and dramatic programs. Approximately half the graduates participate in the full IB diploma program and many attend top quality universities. Alumni often express great affection and appreciation for the school and its teachers. The location is lovely with beautiful vistas and the weather is spectacular if not perfect. There are new facilities in a beautiful new artificial turf field and a teacher-student created butterfly garden.

 
Evaluation 4). Win Sargent 2003 - 2005
 
 
Academic integrity of school
2
Effectiveness of administration
3
Academic and disciplinary support provided
2
Director's involvement in academics
1
Fair and equitable treatment by board and director
2
School has adequate educational materials on hand
4
Attitude of local community towards foreigners
9
Cost of living in relation to salary (10= most favorable)
4
Satisfaction with housing
4
Community offers a variety of activities
8
Availability and quality of local health care
5
Assistance with visas, shipping and air travel
5
Extra curricular load is reasonable
5
           
Comments: Previous comments were, laughably, attributed to me by the Superintendent. It will come as now surprise then that I state he offers a weak and bigoted leadership to the school. Over the years he has forced out competent/excellent members of staff simply because they question his method of [non]running the school.

He finds women, homosexuals and intelligence threatening...and everyone that has been forced out of the school falls into that camp. Fortunately for the children of the school, he leaves this year. Shame then that no one on the board has sought to speed this process up a bit.

Prospective staff need to be aware that they will lose their final months salary as I do not know the last person that received theirs. Bogus bills and inflated charges manage to take care of whatever was due.

The current leader of the school has seen fit to ruin the chances of many teachers to get employment following on from working at CIC. My STRONG recommendation is that you neither work there nor send your children to study there ~ which is sad because many excellent teachers and students are there. I hope that 2007 bring better things to this institution.

 
Evaluation 3). Win Sargent 2000 - 2005
 
 
Academic integrity of school
2
Effectiveness of administration
1
Academic and disciplinary support provided
2
Director's involvement in academics
1
Fair and equitable treatment by board and director
1
School has adequate educational materials on hand
5
Attitude of local community towards foreigners
9
Cost of living in relation to salary (10= most favorable)
9
Satisfaction with housing
9
Community offers a variety of activities
10
Availability and quality of local health care
9
Assistance with visas, shipping and air travel
5
Extra curricular load is reasonable
9
           

Comments: I am one of the many teachers who was forced to leave CIC because of the Director of the school and my comments will obviously reflect this: Venezuela is an amazing country. It is beautiful and offers an incredible range of activities, from gorgeous Andes to pristine beaches.The first review does not paint an accurate picture of Venezuela. It makes the country seem dangerous and unstable, whereas this is not the truth. Safety concerns are the same for Caracas as for any other major city in the world: New York, Paris, Tokyo, etc. It is safe to go out at night as long as one uses common sense. The only shortages of goods occurred during the management-imposed work-stoppage in December '02- January '03, and even this was minimal.The exchange controls result in MORE value for the dollar, not less.

There is great unfairness as to local teachers' salaries, and the local staff has been especially hard hit with inflation because they are paid in local currency. The administration and board do very little to offset these hardships, and the local staff are forced to walk a very thin line as to demands because unemployment in Venezuela is high and the director will get rid of anyone who speaks up too loudly. However, the local staff are very professional and do not harbor "deep-seated jealousy". They merely want to earn what is fair and reasonable- they do not in any way blame the foreign hires (although they could because for the most part the foreign hires only concern themselves with themselves and not the good of the whole of the school).

The first review was more accurate on the description of the school itself. In general, students ARE unmotivated, there IS a real lack of academic standards, and the administration DOES refuse to support teachers. The elementary program is fairly strong, and the real problems arise in the middle school and high school areas. Most of the problems are a direct result of the leadership of the school. The director micro-manages, and does not allow, in any form, criticisms of the educational program. The director not only pushes out people who speak up (about local salaries, about the way staff are treated, about low academic standards, about unfair hiring practices, etc.) but makes sure they are blacklisted (blackballed) with other international schools.

The Board of Directors is a joke, at most meetings they are unable to even reach a quorum. Many parents are more interested in a good grade for their children than the quality of education received, and the administration bows to the pressure (for example, one policy stated that if a student didn't do the work AT ALL they would receive a 60%, not a zero, because it would otherwise mess up their average). There are a few terrible teachers and support staff who enjoy a cozy relationship with the head and therefore have job protection. For the most part, the teachers are qualified and professional and the terrible academic standards are not a result of the teachers, but in spite of them. Teachers absolutely receive incorrect information as regards to shipping and monies owed to them, and the Director tells different people different things. The rules change as he sees fit (with almost zero oversight from the "board") and there is no avenue to address these problems. Basically assume your contract is worth nothing unless you happen to get in good with the Director.

Morale at the school reached an incredible low during the last few school years, with the result being a high turnover of expat teachers. The problem is, and will continue to be, the Director (helped by the Board), who have fired most of the staff for two reasons: 1. teachers were developing friendships with the staff and 2. they can hire new staff for a lot less than they have to pay staff that have been there a long period of time. People were becoming too vocal, so the result was to clean house. The good news is that the director may have only one more year left before retirement. Hopefully, the school can do a good purging and recover its promise.

A comment in a previous review is simply outrageous. "Everyone who works and studies there is highly motivated, enthusiastic and comfortable about the school." This is an absurd statement that couldn't even be true of the most amazing school in the world. Everyone? And it is a well known opinion among many teachers at the school (there are some that would disagree) that the students are not motivated or enthusiastic about the school (maybe comfortable, because they know they will not be held to high academic standards).

The political problems are by no means "resolved", although that should not be held against the country or the school. The political nature of Venezuela is fascinating and multi-faceted. As far as ECA is concerned, of course they are "aggressively lobbying international companies to send their employees' children to their school." That malicious rumors" ideas sounds a little far-fetched. The reality is that ECA is in a better position because it has better academic standards (and their location in the city and better facilities also help). It's interesting to note that while CIC's enrollment has plummeted, ECA's has remained steady. There are many dedicated, hard-working teachers at CIC. If the Director leaves (which MOST of the teachers want but cannot speak up publicly or will lose their jobs) along with his small support network of teachers, and if the board ceases to be a joke and in a power play becomes a real force interested in improving academic standards, then CIC can become an excellent school. Right now, with Mr. Sargent at the helm, the ship is sinking. I hope he gets off before it is too late.

 
Evaluation 2). Win Sargent 1999 - 2005
 
 
Academic integrity of school
10
Effectiveness of administration
8
Academic and disciplinary support provided
10
Director's involvement in academics
10
Fair and equitable treatment by board and director
8
School has adequate educational materials on hand
8
Attitude of local community towards foreigners
8
Cost of living in relation to salary (10= most favorable)
7
Satisfaction with housing
8
Community offers a variety of activities
8
Availability and quality of local health care
8
Assistance with visas, shipping and air travel
8
Extra curricular load is reasonable
8
           

Comments: I've read the other comments made about this school, and they are unreasonably biased and unfair. They must have been made by someone who had an isolated bad experience and is bitter, or by someone whose intention it is to cause harm to the school. CIC is a wonderful school. Everyone who works and studies there is highly motivated, enthusiastic and comfortable about the school. There were political problems in the country over the past couple of years, but they are basically resolved by now and the quality of life here is excellent. There is a crime problem as there is in all of Latin America, but I would add that it is much more manageable than in other Latin American countries. I have lived here for 10 years and never had a problem.

Enrollment has gone down a bit over the past few years because many companies have limited the number of expat workers due to political and economic problems in the country, and also because the American school, Escuela Campo A!legre has made it their policy to sabotage CIC by spreading malicious rumors that the school was closing and by aggressively lobbying international companies to send their employees' children to their school without offering them a chance to visit CIC as well. Comments such as the one made on your web site about CIC are very unfortunate and an untrue portrait of a worthy educational institution and a group of excellent, dedicated educators.

 
Evaluation 1). Win Sargent 2001 - 2003
 
 
Academic integrity of school
10
Effectiveness of administration
2
Academic and disciplinary support provided
2
Director's involvement in academics
8
Fair and equitable treatment by board and director
2
School has adequate educational materials on hand
2
Attitude of local community towards foreigners
4
Cost of living in relation to salary (10= most favorable)
4
Satisfaction with housing
7
Community offers a variety of activities
8
Availability and quality of local health care
4
Assistance with visas, shipping and air travel
4
Extra curricular load is reasonable
3
           
Comments: Venezuela is a beautiful country. However, for this particular school its future is fading. Going from an enrollment of 650 students to 200 or below this past year it has experienced a number of pressures. Students are unmotivated, there is a real lack of academic standards, and the administration refuses to support teachers. All students are IB candidates even if they are unable to read at level. Scores across the board for this school continue to fall and there is no real plan for reform. It basically is a country club--private school for rich Venezuelan students. Last year there were maybe 3-5 American and British students at the school. All the good talented ex-pat students go to ECA downtown--the "embassy school".

Crime is very high and it is dangerous to go out at night. There are constant demonstrations, political unrest, and even deaths at some of these. Some teachers have been mugged in front of their apartments, and held at gun point just blocks from the school by criminals. There are exchange controls on the dollar in which a teacher loses real money. This combined with 40% inflation rate eats away at your savings and disposable cash flow.

There are shortages of poultry, flour, and other goods due to economic problems. Teachers experience incorrect information on shipping, and late return on monies owed. The local staff harbors deep-seated jealously in regards to salaries. Expect to be micro managed on a weekly basis. Assessments are done or not done at the whim of the principle, and you will not get a signed evaluation.